WONDERPROOF EYE PENCIL 101 Butter Matt: Lasting Elegance

Look, the WONDERPROOF EYE PENCIL 101 in Butter Matt is basically that ride-or-die liner you've been searching for. This baby's made in Germany and seriously doesn't budge—we're talking waterproof, humidity-proof, the whole nine yards. You put it on in the morning, and it's still looking fresh when you're finally crawling into bed at night.

Honestly? It works for everything. Rocking a natural look for work? Check. Going all out for date night or a fancy event? Double check. The color payoff is insane, and you get clean, precise lines every single time. Plus, at 0.04 ounces, it's tiny enough to toss in literally any bag without thinking twice about it. If you want an eye pencil that actually does what it says and looks good doing it, this is your guy.